Online Exclusive: NFL Draft Grades!
a.k.a Evolution’s attempt at connecting with the elusive OCSA Sports Fans
Nick Charles Currie - Occasional Writer and Football Enthusiast (and Prom King)
The vast majority of these grades were written during the draft. All picks after the Redskins’ trade for Montez Sweat were done after the draft because I was cohosting a draft analysis show. Only one pick was edited and that will be clearly marked with my explanation for the change.
Arizona Cardinals: Kyler Murray, QB, Oklahoma
Grade: B-
I’m a fan of Kyler Murray. He’s a very good quarterback who should be incredibly successful in Kliff Kingsbury’s system. Because of how good he is, I’m not too upset about this pick. That said, Josh Rosen is a decent quarterback and they shouldn’t be dumping him one year after trading up to select him. They also have yet to find a trade partner for him, so they aren’t getting anything back.
San Francisco 49ers: Nick Bosa, DE, OSU
Grade: B+
I’m not a huge fan of Bosa because he has a lot of trouble against offensive tackles with long arms. That said, he fits the scheme and is the safest player in the class. He’s a talented player who does very well against tackles with lesser reach. Long tackles will give him trouble, but there are enough mediocre/short tackles that Bosa will have a very good career.
New York Jets: Quinnen Williams, DT, Alabama
Grade: A+
Quinnen Williams is the best player in the draft by a long way. He’s just amazing and will be a ton of fun to watch right next to Leonard Williams. Great pick. He’s and athletic tackle who dominates everyone in his path but is soft spoken off the field. He seems like a decent human being and may already be the second best defensive tackle in the NFL.
Oakland Raiders: Clelin Ferrell, DE, Clemson
Grade: B
I honestly don’t know how to feel about this pick. I think I like it but I had him going much later. I think they could’ve traded down and still gotten him. He’s a great player, so I don’t hate the pick. He’s one of the premier technicians at the position in this draft, so he’s not likely to bust. That said, they could have gotten him for much cheaper.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Devin White, LB, LSU
Grade: C+
Devin White is a high potential player, but he’s very raw. He still has trouble tackling and fulfilling his assignment. They weren’t good at teaching Kwon Alexander, I don’t know that this will be any different.
New York Giants: Daniel Jones, QB, Duke
Grade: F
He’s a high floor, low ceiling player. I hate this pick so much. He’s accurate, but not that accurate. He’s almost mobile, but not quite. This pick is one that I detest because he’s not someone who has a chance to be a top ten player in the league, but he was taken at six. He’s been drafted to sit and develop, but he doesn’t have much room to develop.
Jacksonville Jaguars: Josh Allen, EDGE, Kentucky
Grade: B+
I like the player and like that he has amazing company to learn from. I don’t like that they ignored their offensive line, but I like that he has the chance to realize his potential.
Winning moment so far was Allen trying to put the hat on his kid. That was adorable
Detroit Lions: TJ Hockenson, TE, Iowa
Grade: B+
Hockenson is a very good player who can block and receive. He’s a very good TE and he should be very successful for Detroit. I think that they should’ve gone with the defensive side of the ball, but he’s a good player and I can’t really fault them. That said, it does reek of Eric Ebron/Aaron Donald. He’s a better rounded prospect than Ebron, but it’s still somewhat questionable
Buffalo Bills: Ed Oliver, DT, Houston
Grade: B+
Ed Oliver is a fantastic player whose stats were diminished by the fact that he played over the center for his entire career. He should be a great producer at the NFL level and I think that he will be a fantastic addition to the team. I wish they got Josh Allen some help, but I still can’t dislike the pick. They need to get Juwaan Taylor or Dalton Risner in the next round though (that last sentence was written after the draft)
Denver Broncos: TRADE to Pittsburgh Steelers: Devin Bush, LB, Michigan
Grade: A
This would be an A+ if not for his outfit. He’s an amazing player who fills a massive hole on the Steelers roster. This is my favorite pick so far. Bush is almost as athletic as Devin White, but he’s a more polished player. it wouldn’t shock me if some teams had higher grades on Bush than they did on White.
Cincinnati Bengals: Jonah Williams, OT, Alabama
Grade: A
They had a massive need at tackle. This gives new coach Zac Taylor a year to work with Dalton and see what he thinks and it helps the Bengals prepare for the future as well. Great selection.
Green Bay Packers: Rashan Gary, DL, Michigan
Grade: F
Eww. This is a terrible pick. He’s not much of a scheme fit, he’s not a great player, and he isn’t a need. This is my least favorite pick so far. He’s not a football player, he’s just an athlete.
Miami Dolphins: Christian Wilkins, DT, Clemson
Grade: B+
Honestly, anything other than a QB is a good pick here. They want a QB next year, so they are fine with losing this year. Wilkins won’t singlehandedly give you more wins, but he makes your team better. This is a great player. He’s also a great person who moonlights as a substitute teacher and had his teammate who was suspended for drug usage move in with him to help the guy kick the habit. Miami should be very happy that they got one of the best people in the draft.
Atlanta Falcons: Chris Lindstrom, OG, Boston College
Grade: A-
I really like this pick. Lindstrom is a great player and they needed help at guard. It was so widely accepted that they’d take a DT that I went with it as well, but it filled a need and he’s the best OG in the draft.
Washington Redskins: Dwayne Haskins, QB, Ohio State
Grade: A
Haskins is a very solid quarterback who needs a good supporting cast. He may not have the receivers he’d like, but he’s got the offensive line. This is a good pick that lets them play win now.
Carolina Panthers: Brian Burns, EDGE, FSU
Grade: B+
This was a pick most people expected and it was the right pick. They needed young help along the line and they got it with Burns. I’m personally a bit lower on him than most, but he’s got the potential to be very good, and even I had him going higher than this
New York Giants: Dexter Lawrence, DT, Clemson
Grade: F
Why can the Giants not draft? That was bad. They still don’t have a capable right tackle and they had one who fell into their hands. I hate this so much. I recognize that they need a guy to replace Damon Harrison, who they traded for a fifth round pick, but they could’ve gotten someone like that next round and helped their offense now. This is a terrible draft for the Giants already and I don’t know if it can be salvaged.
Minnesota Vikings: Garrett Bradbury, C, NC State
Grade: B-
I like Bradbury a lot. He’s a good player. That said, they have Pat Elflein, who is decent, and Juwaan Taylor is a better player who is still available
EDIT: Grade: B+
I was informed that Pat Elflein was actually PFF’s worst center in the league and that he’ll be kicked outside to guard, where he’s a better fit. This is a very good pick with that knowledge.
Tennessee Titans: Jeffery Simmons, DT, Mississippi State
Grade: C+
Simmons is an amazing player, but they lost two edge rushers and Montez Sweat was available. Sweat could’ve turned them into a playoff team. Instead, they went with a guy who might not even play next year. He’s one of the best players in the draft but they should try for more of an instant impact who also has high potential. Sweat would’ve given them that. It’s also hard to get over Simmons’ character concerns. Not my favorite pick.
Pittsburgh Steelers: TRADE to Denver Broncos: Noah Fant, TE, Iowa
Grade: B+
The Broncos have not had a good tight end for many years. This gives them a great weapon in the pass game. This was a fantastic pick that should have a higher grade, but I’m a Chargers fan.
Seattle Seahawks: TRADE to Green Bay Packers: Darnell Savage, S, Maryland
Grade: A-
He’s one of my favorite safeties and he’s mostly a centerfielder. That’s an amazing pick for what the Packers needed. Dropped to an A- because they probably didn’t need to trade up to get Savage.
Baltimore Ravens: TRADE to Philadelphia Eagles: Andre Dillard, OT, WSU
Grade: A
Dillard is an amazing pass blocker who the Texans needed. This was a smart trade and it prepares them for when Peters retires. Great pick.
Houston Texans: Tytus Howard, OT, Alabama State
Grade: C+
I am not a big fan of this pick. He was dominant against lesser competition, but I’m not sure how he’ll be against NFL players. There are many better offensive tackles available and Tytus Howard is just too much of a question mark when we haven’t seen him play against quality competition. This should have been Risner or Taylor.
Oakland Raiders: Josh Jacobs, RB, Alabama
Grade: B
He would’ve been available at their next pick or even at thirty five. He’s a good player and he fills a huge need, but I don’t think it’s what they needed to do here. They could’ve had Tillery or Sweat and either would’ve been better.
Philadelphia Eagles: TRADE: Baltimore Ravens: Marquise Brown, WR, Oklahoma
Grade: D
I don’t like this. Lamar Jackson was not accurate last year and Marquise Brown is tiny. I loved the idea of him reuniting with Kyler Murray because he’s accurate. Jackson is not an accurate enough quarterback at this point to warrant the selection of Marquise Brown
Indianapolis Colts: TRADE to Washington Redskins: Montez Sweat
Grade: B
I like Montez Sweat, but Dwayne Haskins needs more help than he has. They should’ve gotten someone like AJ Brown who can get separation and create easy throws. They already have a great defense; this should’ve improved their offense.
Oakland Raiders: Johnathan Abram, S, Mississippi State
Grade: D+
I don’t like this pick. They have Karl Joseph, who, while not great, is not bad and he’s still young. There were much bigger needs that had better players available. Abram is good, but not as good as Tillery or someone of that calliber
Los Angeles Chargers: Jerry Tillery, DT, Notre Dame
Grade: A+
As a Chargers fan, this was the pick I’d been hoping for throughout the entire draft process. He’s a fantastic player, being a threat both against the run and as a pass rusher. He’ll make life even more difficult for opposing quarterbacks and it helps stop the run. This is an amazing pick that I love. It’s one of my favorites in the draft.
Seattle Seahawks: L.J. Collier, DE, TCU
Grade: G
Why did they do this? Sure, they need a defensive end, but it’s not that likely that Collier goes before the Seahawks’ next pick. They could’ve taken Nasir Adderley or Cody Ford, but they didn’t for some puzzling reason. This was an awful pick and shouldn't have happened. This gets even lower than an F because they traded their next pick as well, which they should’ve used for either of the aforementioned players.
Seattle Seahawks: TRADE to New York Giants: Deandre Baker, CB, Georgia
Grade: D
It’s only not an F because he’s a good player who kind of fills a need. However, they had two great RTs available: Dalton Risner and Juwaan Taylor. Neither should have fallen out of the first round and both would have fit for the Giants. I don’t hate this pick as much as the last one or the next one, but I still hate it
Los Angeles Rams: TRADE to Atlanta Falcons: Kaleb McGary, RT, Washington
Grade: F
He’s not the best RT available and he’s not even worthy of a first round pick. He certainly wasn’t worth getting rid of your second and third round picks for. Terrible pick with both Dalton Risner and Juwaan Taylor on the board
New England Patriots: N’Keal Harry, WR, ASU
Grade: B+
N’Keal Harry is a very good player who fills a need. He does not, however, fill their biggest need: tight end. I don’t think they’ll wind up with Irv Smith now and I don’t know if they’ll be able to get Jace Sternberger either. That is a major loss for a team that just lost one of the best tight ends of all time